These five products are candidates for a one-bottle comparison, not five completed checkout tests. The sections distinguish what the available records show from what remains unresolved. Older offer paragraphs retain their October 1 context unless an update below explicitly replaces them.

Define the commitment you want before comparing a discount. Record what is due now, whether another charge is authorized and how the selected terms describe cancellation. An item price, a purchase button and a completed order answer different questions; our review does not treat them as interchangeable proof.

A calendar, a delivery box and a skincare container.
5 BHA products: one-time purchase checks and subscription limits — keep the next order, the remaining supply and the current label in view together.

The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Solution — leave-on bha serum

The aqueous bottle-size correction is in the updated review. It does not refresh the separate anhydrous product. [1]

The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Solution is a water-based leave-on formula positioned for acne-prone skin. It is distinct from both the anhydrous version and the rinse-off masque. The shared 2% headline does not erase differences in vehicle, product instructions or intended format, and it cannot serve as a guaranteed sensitivity rating.

The November page showed an Add to Cart control; no checkout was tested. Use the dated bottle record before calculating costs. [1]

An unbranded cream jar, tube and serum bottle.
The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Solution — leave-on bha serum — a cream, tube or serum describes a format; the complete formula supplies the context.

The INKEY List Beta Hydroxy Acid — leave-on bha serum

The INKEY List BHA Serum offers a confirmed 30 mL bottle and a visible single-item shipping issue. That makes it useful for calculating the actual one-time commitment. Avoid treating the free-shipping threshold as a reason to buy unneeded products. Its salicylic acid and hyaluronic acid combination remains an active treatment formula, regardless of how simple the retail order is.

The INKEY List BHA Serum is a 30 mL leave-on acne treatment listing 2% salicylic acid and 1% hyaluronic acid. It performs a treatment step rather than cleansing the face. A hydrating ingredient does not cancel every irritation risk, and the current Drug Facts or product directions should be read with any other acne medication.

The direct capture shows $14 for 30 mL, approximately $0.47 per mL before tax and delivery. The page advertises US shipping from $7.95, with some states at $8.95, and free shipping above $40. For a single bottle, the shipping charge can materially change its apparent advantage over another low-priced treatment.

November’s indexed excerpt did not establish a purchase selector. The preceding shipping amounts remain October 1 observations, not confirmed current terms. [3]

Naturium BHA Liquid Exfoliant 2% — leave-on bha exfoliant

For this option, compare the selected purchase mode before comparing the amount due. The evidence update below replaces our earlier uncertainty about whether a recurring option was shown.

Naturium BHA Liquid Exfoliant 2% is a 120 mL leave-on liquid. It should not be confused with Naturium’s salicylic-acid body wash or 360-degree body spray. Keeping those formats distinct prevents a misleading price comparison and avoids applying assumptions about a rinse-off product to a leave-on acid step with different label instructions.

Indexed official text showed one-time purchase alongside optional recurring delivery. It was marked crawled last month; direct access was blocked on November 7. No checkout or current promotion was confirmed. [4]

Skincare containers, a folded towel and an oval mirror.
Naturium BHA Liquid Exfoliant 2% — leave-on bha exfoliant — a product comparison makes more sense alongside the routine already on your shelf.

Peach Slices Acne Exfoliating Toner — leave-on acne toner

Peach Slices offers another 120 mL toner at a lower observed product price. Its page also promotes a larger acne system, which should not be confused with the one-item budget. Read the multi-acid ingredient list and source qualifications. The sensible choice can be the single toner if appropriate, rather than purchasing an entire routine because the brand presents it as step two.

Peach Slices Acne Exfoliating Toner is a 120 mL leave-on toner with 2% salicylic acid plus glycolic and lactic acids. The page attributes some clinical language to ingredient and supplier studies and separately describes consumer work on the acne collection. Those evidence types do not establish an independent head-to-head trial of this bottle against another brand.

The official page shows $10.99 for 120 mL, approximately $0.09 per mL before tax and shipping. That is an observed one-time toner price, not a complete checkout total or an assumed 30-day supply. No unverified subscription or bundle discount is applied; the three-step system is a different, larger purchase.

The indexed record showed Add to Bag. Its subscription panel applied to Peach & Lily Collection products, not an established plan for this Peach Slices bottle. Checkout was not tested. [5]

Paula’s Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant — leave-on bha exfoliant

Paula’s Choice Liquid has a clearly displayed $37 one-time price and a separate subscription amount. Selecting the ordinary purchase mode makes the distinction concrete. It offers a full-size liquid reference with an observed quantity, but costs more upfront than several options here. That difference is a purchasing fact, not proof of stronger performance or a reason to ignore its complete label.

Paula’s Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid is a leave-on liquid, not a cleanser or moisturizer. The current full-size listing is four fluid ounces. Its named salicylic-acid concentration does not reveal the entire tolerability story; the complete base and other products already in the routine remain relevant when comparing a liquid with a gel.

The official listing shows $37 for four fluid ounces, or $9.25 per fluid ounce before tax. A separate subscription advertises $31.45 and free shipping. Keep one-time and recurring modes separate; a promotion or first-order benefit does not establish future pricing, and the actual delivery interval should be checked before enrollment.

Current access to the Liquid page was unavailable on November 7. The preceding dollar amounts and auto-refill description remain October 1 observations. [6]

Skincare containers, a folded towel and an oval mirror.
Paula’s Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant — leave-on bha exfoliant — a product comparison makes more sense alongside the routine already on your shelf.

Read the commitment before authorizing the order

A discount is useful only within the purchase you intend to make. Compare the selected mode and package first, then the total due. If a recurring option is selected, write down the later amount and interval separately rather than treating the first charge as the whole commitment.

Keep a copy of the final order summary and the terms that apply to that selection. If the page leaves a material term unclear, resolve it before payment. This checklist is a recordkeeping method; it does not guarantee the operation of any seller’s cancellation or delivery process.

Fields to confirm in the selected order
FieldWhat to recordUnresolved means
Purchase modeOne order or recurring authorizationDo not assume from a button alone
Due nowItem, delivery, tax and discountsThe headline is not the total
Next chargeDate or interval and amount, if anyThe commitment is incomplete
CancellationWhere, when and on what termsKeep the question open
PackageExact item and quantityDo not borrow another variant’s size

Before choosing an option

Return policies and current manufacturer instructions are worth reading before payment, particularly if you have a history of reactions. Do not open several active products at once in an attempt to reproduce a ranked list. Choose the product role you need and retain the label. This comparison describes purchase terms observed on October 1, 2026; it does not claim unlimited availability, guaranteed cancellation of every unrelated order or personal suitability for a particular skin condition.

Sources and verification

Official pages establish product facts and provider claims. Clinical and regulatory sources answer separate evidence questions. Article checked October 1, 2026; individual source dates appear below. No medical reviewer is credited for this article.